Tuesday, 29 January 2013

HCJ4: Phenomenology/Existentialism

Notes from book

Edmund Husserl sought to re-invent psychology by combine it with ideas from philosophy to from a new discipline called 'phenomenology'.

The aim of phenomenology was to study the immediate data of consciousness, but without referring to anything that consciousness might tell us about the extra- mental world - that is anything outside of our own minds. The PMW book gives an example of a phoenix, "the intentionality of my thought [of the phoenix] is exactly the same whether or not there are any phoenixes in reality". Husserl also gave an example in his writings, he thought of the planet Jupiter as he thought of Bismarck and of the tower of Babel as he thought of Cologne Cathedral. He made the point that the intentionality of his experience is the same whether the object is really there or if it is a hallucination. For example, if I see a table, it makes no difference whether it is actually there or not.

Husserl explained that a phenomenologist should closely study the psychological phenomena (situations that are observed to exist or happen) and should take the attitude of suspended judgement when dealing with the extra-mental world, Husserl uses the Greek word 'epoche' for suspense of judgement. 'Epoche' is the process of thinking away from the natural interpretation of an experience to concentrate on its intrinsic nature (belonging to a thing by its very nature, its inherent nature).

Husserl didn't assert that there were no realities other than phenomena and left the possibility of a world of non-phenomenal objects, but such objects are of no concern to the philosopher. Husserl said the reason for this is that we have infallible knowledge of the objects in our own consciousness while our knowledge of the external world is inferential (deriving logical conclusions from premises that are known or assumed to be true).

Husserl distinguished between immanent and transcendent perception. Immanent is self-evident and operates inside a thing or a person. Transcendent perception is fallible and the inferences that constitute transcendent perception actually based on deliverances from immanent perception. This makes immanent perception more fundamental.

Phenomenology is the most basic of all disciplines because only consciousness has 'absolute being' and all other forms depend on consciousness for their existence. Phenomenology also provides the data and information of all other branches of philosophy and science.

Husserl made epoche more radical than Cartesian doubt (the method of being doubtful or sceptical, it invites us to suspend judgement on any proposition whose truth can be doubted. This process is dramatised as the 'evil demon', it causes us to doubt everything we thought we knew. Descartes came up with the demon proof point of certainty, the cogito 'I think therefore I am'. It is on this slender basis that the correct use of our faculties has to be re-established).

Husserl also tried to combine his ideas of solipsism (the idea that the self is the only thing that can be known to exist) with a solution to the problem of intersubjectivity (the 'agreement' between individuals in a situation).


Existentialism (John Paul Satre)

Satre's pre war essays are detailed studies in the philosophy of mind in the phenomenological mould. Satre criticised Husserl in that he hadn't taken the phenomenological reduction far enough. Satre disagreed with Husserl's accepting that Cartesian ego (aware of its own thoughts and capable of disembodied existence) as a datum of consciousness. Satre said that when we are absorbed in what we are doing, we have not thought of ourselves and we only make the self an object when reflecting on the situation. The self lies outside of consciousness and therefore belongs to the transcendent world (a world of the superior. It goes beyond normal limits).

Satre showed that the perception that in imagination we are surveying the contents of an interior mental world is false. Satre said that we are imagining extra-mental objects, not internal images. An example is if we imagine a real person but who is absent, We are creating an object in the world when what we imagine doesn't exist.

According to Satre, emotions are misconceived if we think of them as passive internal feelings. If we hate someone, we actually perceive them as hateful. Satre also used depression to explain a 'magical transformation' of the situations we are in. He said that depression 'casts a spell' on the world to make every effort to cope seem pointless.

Being, for Satre, is what precedes and underlies all the different kinds of things we encounter in consciousness. We sort things into classes depending on our interests and as instruments for our purposes. If we strip away all the distinctions, we're left with pure being. Being in itself - l'en soi. This is 'without reason, without cause, without necessity'.

Satre expanded a theme of Heidegger's. English philosophers laughed at 'nothing' noths' but Satre expanded on it to give it some significance. When consciousness articulates the world, it does so y means of negation. Satre uses the example of the concept of red. He divides the world into red and non-red. An example given in PMW is of chairs and tables, we must divide chairs into two groups - chairs and not-tables and therefore tables and not-chairs. Satre says that 'the being by which nothingness comes into the world must be its own nothingness'.

Another of Satre's ideas comes from Heidegger. For most objects essence precedes existence but Satre said in his book 'Exitenialism and Humanism', "there is at least one being whose existence comes before his essence, a being which exists before it can be defined by any conception of it. That being is man". Human freedom precedes the essence of man. Humans don't need to follow a set life path. Satre says that human freedom creates a fissure in the world of objects. The life of an individual is not determined in advance, neither by a creator nor by necessitating causes nor by absolute moral laws. We can't escape the necessity to choose though. Satre also talked about 'bad faith', this is when we are aware of our freedom but strive to reduce ourselves to mere objects.

The alternative attitude is to accept our freedom and accept responsibility for our actions. Satre says that there are psychical limits, but we will adapt our desires depending on the situations that we find ourselves in.

Satre introduced the idea of 'being-for-others-, this is the way in which we are presented to others and are observed by them; We become nothing more than an object for them - maybe of envy or contempt.

Satre followed Communist Party ideas. A key idea of existentialism was libertarianism, this was hard to reconcile with Marxist determinists though.


Notes from lecture

Husserl's book 'psychology from an empirical standpoint' is the foundation text of modern phenomenology and is an attempt to de-mystify psychology, which had its origins in Hegelian pseudo-science such as phrenology (the study of the the shape and size of skulls, it is based on the discredited idea that doing so could reveal mental capacity etc...)

Heidegger's book 'being in time' was one of the great works of that time. The primary idea of the metaphysical age is to make thoughts correspond with an underlying or hidden substrata of independentley subsisting reality (such as Schopenhauer's 'will').

Heidegger wouldn't agree with the slogan of the X Files "the truth is out there".

Truth is the agreement of knowledge with objects. Objects are eternal and prior to the mind (Aristotle) and can be mind dependent, (Kant) but they exist either way according to the metaphysicians. Kant didn't want to reject metaphysics, but to reform it and his project was to re-foundation it.

After Heidesgger, there is no absolute or higher truth. There are only subjective 'weak truths' that people don;t really believe. There are also 'convenient truths' also called 'practical truths'. For Heidegger, being is always specific or concrete.

Heidegger's project was to clear away all the philosophical terminology and throw away all philosophical concepts and systems since Socrates. Like Nietzsche, Heidegger believes Socrates corrupted western civilization.

Dasein or 'being there'. 'Being' at a particular time and place, as well as being engaged in a particular task. There is no existence when the being is Dasein. All troubles go away when in Dasein ('in the zone').

Existence is boredom and boredom is the 'problem of being'. The opposite of boredom is existence and your Dasein.

Monday, 21 January 2013

BBC College of Journalism write up

This is a short blog explaining how some of the how-to videos on the BBC College of Journalism website can help me during my time on WINOL and as my time as a sports reporter this semester.
I watched three videos on the website and have identified some that will be useful for me whilst on WINOL and how I can use them for my role as a sports reporter.

The first video I watched was about writing to pictures, presented by BBC News senior producer Mark Georgiou. The first tip given on the video is to look at the pictures before writing the script. Although this is something drummed into us on WINOL, it was good to see how top BBC journalists such as Nicolas Witchel go about their business, the example of the royal wedding in 2011 was used. From watching the BBC COJO's video, I have seen how professional journalists do it and will be able to write to pictures better. A point that Mark Georgiou makes is this, "it's the pictures that inspire the memorable lines". In my view, this doesn't just apply to producing news packages, it also applies to producing football highlights packages. Say for example a player scores a fantastic goal, but whilst watching the game through the lens of the camera, you don't get time to appreciate how good the goal was. By watching the footage back you can see how good the goal was and it should inspire you to think of a great way to describe the action.

Another tip given in the video is that sound is as important as vision. This applies mainly to news packages, but also the football highlights packages. From watching the programme 'The Football League Show' (a programme we have identified as one that is good to look at for inspiration), I have seen just how important natural sound is in a highlights package. For example, if a goal is scored, the person commentating on the action doesn't talk over much of the goal and celebration. He lets the natural sound speak for him, he doesn't need to tell us that the stadium has 'erupted' because we can hear the crowd cheering.

The third tip given is to talk to the picture editor. We do everything on our news and sports packages, including filming, editing and scripting, but when I am going through the rushes, I am asking myself 'what shot should I open with', 'would it work better if I switched that sentence around?', according to Georgiou, these questions are the same that reporters ask picture editors all the time. I can relate this to the sports package I was editing today. I had to make the sequence a bit shorter in order to accomodate the length of script I had written.

Georgiou talks about reporters talking to themselves whilst writing their scripts to make sure that what they're writing sounds OK. I have made the mistake before of not reading aloud what I have written down and then recording it. This meant I had to re-write the script in a short space of time.

The second how-to video I watched was about how to ask simple questions in an interview. I've watched the same video before and I tried to follow the video and ask simple questions during interviews last semester, but by watching the video again I can apply it to my new role as sports reporter. Whenever I have to interview a football manager or player, I will ask simple questions, because from what I saw in the video, you're likely to get better answers. A question that Jeremy Paxman asks a prisoner is "how do you find it?", the prisoner then gives a simple yet effective response. When an interviewer asks a long winded question, it might put off the interviewee and confuse them slightly. When interviewing managers before or after football matches, I will make sure to ask simple and direct questions, hopefully this will give me some good quotes.

The final video I watched was about how to get interviewees to open up. I found this quite difficult last semester as a news reporter, especially trying to get councillors to open up on issues like why they had chosen to charge motorists to park in a car park or if they were defending their high earnings (just two examples of challenging interviews I faced). In terms of my role as a sports reporter, I will have to ask questions that get managers or players to open up about e.g. how their team did after a defeat or after a refereeing decision he wasn't happy about. More often than not, managers like to talk about a game they have won, but not so much when they lose, so this is something I will have to get around.

Sunday, 30 December 2012

WHU blog: 2012/13 mid-season review.


Getting promoted to the Premier League was as much of a relief as a joyous occasion for West Ham fans. Another season in the Championship would have done a lot of damage to the club, not just financially but to the squad as many of the players probably would have left. The players did a great job to beat Blackpool in the play-off final at Wembley, with Ricardo Vaz Te scoring the winning goal in the 87th minute.

Pre-season didn’t go as well as the Irons would have hoped. Four defeats and two draws may have left fans worrying about the season ahead, but as the first few games were played it became clear that the fans should have no cause for concern unless something were to go drastically wrong. Only one loss in the first five games left West Ham 8th in the Premier League, two places above their rivals Tottenham.

After the first 5 games, it was obvious that West Ham’s most important player was going to be Mohamed Diame. He bossed the midfield in every game, stopping the opposition’s attackers from threatening the goal as well as getting forward when needed.

Wins against QPR and Southampton pushed West Ham up to 7th place and a home defeat to Arsenal sandwiched between those two wins did nothing to stop the players performing in the way they had been in the previous games. After the 4-1 win over Southampton, the Irons played poorly against Wigan and lost 2-1. An early goal from Ivan Ramis, (a player who may well have been at West Ham over the summer) scored after 8 minutes and West Ham never seemed to recover.

The next game was against the Premier League champions Manchester City. The expectations of West Ham fans were understandably quite low, but a good home record gave them some hope. They defended resolutely and were unlucky to see Kevin Nolan’s volley ruled offside. Manchester City were unable to break down the West Ham defence was the game ended 0-0, a very good result for West Ham indeed.

The next two games gave West Ham 4 points, an away win against Newcastle which was an unexpected result in many ways. A home draw against Stoke wasn’t the result the fans would have hoped for though. The Potters dominated the first half and scored after 13 minutes but couldn’t extend their lead. The second half belonged to West Ham and a rare goal from Joey O’Brien levelled the game, but his team were unable to go on and win the game.

Two defeats in a row against Spurs and Manchester United left West Ham in 10th place, but they got up to 8th win a superb win over Chelsea. Many must have thought it was going to be West Ham’s third defeat in a row when Juan Mata scored after 13 minutes, but Chelsea couldn’t extend their lead. A goal from Carlton Cole mid-way through the second half put West Ham the front foot. Mohamed Diame put West Ham 2-1 up with only 4 minutes remaining and Modibo Maiga got the winner in the 93rd minute. It was the best game of West Ham’s season up until then and will probably end up being the best win of their season.

Since then, things haven’t gone quite as well for the Irons. They probably should have got something out of the game against Liverpool, but it was pretty much lost when Diame went off with an injury. The next match saw West Ham drawing 0-0 with West Brom, a good result for the Irons and a deserved point in the end.

West Ham suffered two defeats in a row in their next two games, a 2-1 home loss to Everton was especially worse as Carlton Cole was sent off and the circumstances surrounding it arguably led to the game ending in defeat for the home side. Losing away to Reading didn’t come as a surprise as Reading were just starting to find their feet in the Premier League and needed to win that game. In the end I think they wanted it more than West Ham.

It hasn’t been a bad season at all for the Irons - 6 wins, 5 draws and 8 defeats after playing 19 games is pretty good for a team fresh from the Championship. Games against Sunderland and Norwich stand out as games they should have got more out of, but a win against Chelsea and draw against Manchester City go some way to making up for those draws. If things go as they have been so far this season, West Ham should finish mid table. They won’t be challenging for a place in Europe but won’t be sucked into the relegation battle.

Wednesday, 12 December 2012

WINOL critical review – Semester 1.


WINOL has been a success overall. The website has greatly improved since the first few weeks and has a professional looking layout, this is mainly due to the change from Joomla to Wordpress. News bulletins have been good in terms of the news agenda each week and the running order for each bulletin. In the first few weeks the order was a lot of packages one after the other, but the editors decided to have a ‘coming up’ piece after a couple of packages to keep viewers watching. Another feature introduced into the bulletins that worked well at keeping viewer’s attention was an OOV belt after a few of the packages.

The production team has been particularly impressive. As I have been operating the studio cameras for the bulletins over the course of this semester and also operated the autocue for the last bulletin, this has meant that I have had an idea of how stressful it can be to work on production. Everyone on the team has done their jobs well and stayed professional throughout each bulletin.

Other parts of WINOL I have been impressed with are sport and features. Football highlights packages have been put together well and sports news stories/features have been interesting. Sportsweek has been slightly disappointing in that it is usually 4 packages played one after the other wiht links in between each one, maybe next semster a Football League Show style programme could replace this format. Features work has got better over the course of the semester, including the two confessional interviews with Hitler’s ex-neighbour and Paul Blackburn and the work done by the fashion magazine team.

The WINOL website’s Alexa rank was 10,424 in the UK on Monday 10th December and was around 35,000 in the UK at the end of September, this is a huge improvement in just 3 months and the work from news, sport and features have made sure our ranking has steadily improved.

Although we identified a competitor for the website in ‘East London Lines’, it is a shame that we didn’t have competition from other student journalists for the news bulletin, but some packages produced were up to local news bulletin standard.

WINOL did 3 big projects this semester, BJTC awards, HPCC debate and American Election special, even though I wasn’t involved in the BJTC awards, I thought the finished VT was great.

I was involved in the WINOL’s coverage of the American election. There was a bit of confusion in terms of the organisation of the coverage at the start of the semester, but we decided to broadcast a 2 hour programme from 9am to 11am (UK time) on Wednesday 7th November to build up to the result of the election. Due to the election results being announced earlier than we expected, scripts had to be re-worked and everyone appearing on screen had to change almost everything they were going to say. That included me as I was the ‘newsroom expert’ as part of this I provided half hourly updates on the information that was coming in. My task was made a lot more difficult because the election was pretty much over. I was quite nervous the first couple of times I was on screen, but it was the first time I had appeared on screen live and I only had cue cards to guide me to what I was going to say. I was praised by Ian Anderson (a previous editor of BBC News at 10) for the work I did as newsroom expert, something I feel proud for. My only criticism of the 2 hour programme would be that it was decided that another journalism student would take my place for my role as newsroom expert, even though I was supposed to be doing the whole 2 hours.

Even though I had no role during the HPCC debate, the whole thing felt like a professionally run event, rather than a student project.

There were a few things that probably could have been done better on WINOL. At the start of the semester I felt there was a lack of leadership from the editors, but I think that someone ‘stamping their authority’ would have been detrimental to the quality of the work done. I also think that they were ‘bedding in’ to their roles, which we all were in the first weeks.

Another criticism I have is that there were a couple of packages that should have been spiked - including mine from 28th November. We had Geoff Hill coming in as a guest editor that week and so that the bulletin was a good as it could have been, my package probably shouldn’t have been in the bulletin.

In terms of the work I did as a news reporter, some of it was good, but there was room for improvement in most of my packages. I think the camerawork in many of my packages was good. A few examples of this come from the Totton car park package I produced on 31st October, both interviews were framed well as I had one councillor in the left third and the other in the right third. Another package where I composed interview shots well was my package from 28th November. One package where I was disappointed with shot composition was my first package from 10th October. One interview was framed well but the camera was on a tilt and the other interview was framed badly and the councillor filled almost all of the shot.

Although most of my filming was to a good standard, one exception being my package from 24th October. For other packages, I sometimes didn’t get enough shots. A prime example of this was the package I produced on 14th November, it was only 52 seconds in length when it probably should have been 1 minute 10 seconds or even 1 minute 20 seconds, this was due to me not getting enough shots in Southampton. I only filmed the cutaway of Councillor Smith typing from one height and angle as well as not filming enough cutaways around the city. I probably should have interviewed the councillors in different places than I did as the lighting wasn’t great. One thing I was disappointed about that week was that I had agreed with the news editor to do an in- studio discussion about the story, but whilst I was coming back to the newsroom, I was told that the discussion was cancelled and I would have to produce a VT.

Another thing I did well whilst on WINOL was getting balance in my packages, this is especially important as a political reporter. One package where opposing views were most present was from the Totton car park package, one councillor had the view that charging people to park in the car park was justified and the other disagreed with his viewpoint. I made sure I picked the best quotes from each interview to show this.

One VT where I had balance but only had one interview was from 17th October. The balance came from a statement sent to me by the leader of Southampton City Council. I think that if I had got another interview, my package would have got into the bulletin. My final news package for WINOL probably had too much Tory bias, but my second interview had to be done quickly as the councillor was in a rush.

In the first few weeks of WINOL, I had couple of technical problems. The biggest of which was from my package from 24th October, this issue was the main cause for the package not getting into the bulletin. The camera I was using shows whatever you are shooting in the entire screen if you set it to 4:3 view, which made me think that the shot would be OK for TV. The camera should have been in 16:9 view as this is the aspect ratio that was chosen to be used in the bulletin in the second week onwards. Apart from that, I got two interviews that gave the story balance and got some relevant shots.

Probably the worst day I had on WINOL was 21st November. I had planned to up to London to cover the student protests and to send back footage to be used in the bulletin. Once we had filmed everything we had to film, we set about importing, editing and uploading the footage. Importing and editing was easy as we knew what we had filmed was good and what we wanted to upload to Youtube. We were unable to upload the footage that we wanted to upload as the internet connection at the station wasn’t good.

We made a few mistakes that led to us being unable to send back any footage. We should have got at least 10 seconds of footage to the newsroom, but we weren’t told to get back that amount of footage by anyone in charge and I felt that were encouraged to send back as much as possible. We probably should have recorded my PTC at Embankment, not Westminister as this would have saved us at least half an hour, which would have been precious time for editing and uploading some footage. The final mistake we made was that we didn’t do a proper test of the time it would take for us to upload videos to Youtube on a slow internet connection, but we wouldn’t have been able to fully replicate the connection speed we had at Waterloo station. I learned from criticisms we were given and if I get the opportunity to an OB again, I will know what to do if I can’t upload the amount of footage I want.

The final week with a proper bulletin didn’t take its usual course for me. First off, I filmed the Winchester City football match on Saturday 1st December for a fellow student as he was unable to do it.

I had planned a news story for the bulletin, but on the Monday morning it became clear that due to not being able to get interviews, I probably couldn’t have done the package. I wasn’t left without anything to do in this week as the sport editor decided that I would be making two packages of the match I had filmed - a ‘fat minute’ for the news bulletin and an extended highlights package for the Sportsweek programme. A couple of things I learned about making football highlights packages just from this week was to watch the ‘raw footage’ before editing and to write down the clip numbers when a goal is scored or an incident occurs. I also learned a few things after talking to Angus Scott. I think my voiceover on the package was good as I didn’t describe the action or talk over the footage too much. I also made sure I put into practice the advice other sports reporters had been given in previous weeks by Angus Scott.

My performance as a news reporter could have been better and I was disappointed at how inconsistent I was in terms of the packages I made e.g my first package was good for a first effort but I was unable to keep the momentum from that going into the next package. Although I did have two good weeks in a row when I produced the Totton car park package on 31st October and then featured on our coverage of the American Election special on 7th November. My one week as a sports reporter went well, the footage was edited well, my voiceover was good and I got the package in on time.